Overcompensating Movies (2025): A Hilarious and Thoughtful College Comedy

Prime Video’s Overcompensating Movies  (2025) is a sharp and raunchy coming-of-age comedy that explores identity, self-deception, and the pressures of fitting in. Created by Benito Skinner, the series blends outrageous humor with heartfelt moments, making it a standout addition to the college comedy genre.

The story follows Benny (Benito Skinner), a former high school football star who arrives at Yates University with a secret—he’s gay, but not ready to admit it. Determined to maintain his straight persona, Benny gets pulled into a frat-like secret society led by Peter (Adam DiMarco), his sister Grace’s (Mary Beth Barone) boyfriend. Meanwhile, Carmen (Wally Baram), a socially awkward freshman, is also struggling to reinvent herself. Their disastrous attempt at hooking up leads to an unexpected friendship, where they help each other navigate the chaos of college life.

Overcompensating thrives on its mix of absurdity and sincerity. The show satirizes frat culture, social expectations, and the awkwardness of self-discovery while delivering genuinely touching moments. Skinner’s comedic timing and writing shine, making Benny’s journey both hilarious and relatable. The supporting cast, including Rish Shah and Owen Thiele, adds depth to the narrative, ensuring the humor never overshadows the emotional core.

The series’ biggest strength is its ability to balance crude humor with meaningful storytelling. The exaggerated college antics keep the laughs coming, while Benny’s struggle with identity adds emotional weight. However, some viewers may find the humor too over-the-top, and certain plot points feel rushed. Despite this, Overcompensating remains a refreshing and engaging watch.